Testing

7 Email A/B Tests That Actually Grow Revenue

Prefer video? Watch the full tutorial on YouTube.

Quick answer

Stop testing button colours. These seven A/B tests can actually move email revenue: (1) feature lists vs a single customer testimonial, (2) midday vs evening send times, (3) a basic cart email vs one with trust signals and objection handling, (4) a regular vs a mystery discount pop-up, (5) showing vs hiding prices, (6) plain-text vs designed emails, and (7) a round percentage vs an oddly specific store credit. Run one test at a time for about 30 days.

Most brands test the wrong things, or nothing at all

Most Shopify brand owners fall into one of two camps: they don’t test at all and miss real growth, or they test things that don’t matter, like button colours or emojis in subject lines. That’s busy work, not optimisation. Real tests change how you communicate value and build trust. Results depend on your niche, brand and audience, which is exactly why you test.

7 A/B tests worth running

1. Feature list vs customer testimonial

Version A: bullet points of features and benefits, like premium materials, easy instructions and five colours. Version B: replace all of that with one passionate customer testimonial about how the product changed their life.

People trust other customers more than they trust your brand. A feature tells them what something does. A testimonial shows them what it means to own it. Pull testimonials straight from your reviews, or use Klaviyo’s product feed blocks.

2. Send time: midday vs evening

Conventional wisdom says lunchtime, when people check their phones on a break. But I’ve seen a 7 p.m. campaign outperform the same campaign sent at 11 a.m. At noon, people are distracted and rushing. In the evening, they’re winding down, scrolling on the couch or commuting home, in a better headspace to browse and buy.

It’s completely audience-dependent, so test it: duplicate a campaign in Klaviyo, schedule the versions at different times to split halves of your list, and run it for a few weeks. Try morning vs evening, noon vs evening, and so on.

3. Abandoned cart: basic vs objection-handling

Version A: the cart contents, “You left something behind” and a “Complete checkout” button. Version B: add trust signals, like free shipping, review count and a secure checkout badge, plus a short section answering common objections.

Click-through may stay about the same, but conversion can jump. People left for a reason, like shipping concerns or wanting to learn more about you. Answer those questions up front and you remove the friction. Test this in your first cart email. More in the abandoned cart guide.

4. Regular vs mystery discount pop-up

Version A: “Sign up and get $5 off your first order.” Version B: “Sign up for a mystery discount.” Everyone still gets $5 off. They just don’t know it until they sign up.

It can lift both opt-ins and first purchases, thanks to curiosity and gamification: it feels like unlocking a reward rather than getting the discount everyone gets. Some brands worry it feels gimmicky, and that’s fair, so it depends on your positioning. It’s worth testing if your brand voice is playful or your audience is younger. Measure sign-up rate and first-purchase conversion. Run it in Klaviyo or a pop-up tool like Alia.

5. Show prices vs hide prices

For many ecommerce brands, showing prices under each product performs better. If someone opens your email, they’re interested, so making them click just to see the price adds friction, especially on mobile, and people who find it’s out of budget bounce anyway. Showing prices pre-qualifies them before they hit your site.

For luxury or high-ticket products, some mystery may work better. Clone your next campaign, show prices in one version and not the other, and see what your audience prefers.

6. Plain text vs designed email

Version A: pure plain text, with no images, logo or fancy footer, like a personal email from someone you know. Version B: the same copy with your logo, design and a branded footer.

Plain text often wins, sometimes by a lot. Polished emails clearly signal marketing, which makes people defensive. Plain text feels one-to-one, which also helps deliverability. It works especially well for welcome series, win-backs, VIP messages and founder updates, anywhere relationship-building matters more than showing products. In Klaviyo, use a text-only template. Just don’t overdo it, or it loses its impact.

7. Round percentage vs specific store credit

Picture a win-back email. Control: “20% off your next order.” Test: an oddly specific store credit, like “$14.67 credit.” Similar value, completely different framing, and the specific credit can dramatically outperform.

Why? Specificity creates curiosity (why that exact number? Is it based on my past orders?), so it feels personal rather than a mass discount. And store credit feels like money that’s already yours, just waiting to be used. One caution: store credit can lower average order value, so add a minimum spend, like “Use your credit on orders over $45,” to protect margins.

How to run them

  • Pick one test, set it up this week and measure for about 30 days. Then move on to the next.
  • Change one variable at a time, so you know what made the difference.
  • Judge on revenue and conversions, not just opens and clicks.

For your acquisition offer specifically, see how to test your discount strategy.

Frequently asked questions

What should I A/B test in email marketing?

Test things that change how you communicate value: testimonials vs feature lists, send times, objection handling in cart emails, mystery vs regular discounts, showing prices, plain-text vs designed emails, and specific store credit vs percentage discounts.

What is the best time to send marketing emails?

It depends on your audience. Many brands assume lunchtime, but evening sends often perform better. Split-test send times in Klaviyo for a few weeks to find yours.

Do plain-text emails perform better?

Often, especially for welcome, win-back, VIP and founder emails, because they feel personal. Mix them with designed emails rather than replacing them entirely.

How long should an email A/B test run?

Long enough to get meaningful volume, typically a few weeks. Around 30 days per test is a good rule.