Email strategy
Paid Ads vs Email Marketing: Why You Need Both (and in What Order)
In this guide
Quick answer
It isn’t paid ads or email marketing. You need both. Ads are fast, predictable and scalable, but expensive and at the mercy of Meta and Google. Email is far cheaper per touch and you own the list, but it only works once people find you. Set up your email flows first, confirm they convert, then scale ads, so every paid visitor gets retargeted by email for almost nothing. And email isn’t dead. Lazy, product-only emails are.
What paid ads are good and bad at
A media buyer will swear ads are everything, and an email marketer will say email is where the money is. They’re both right, but both miss the point.
The upside of ads: they’re predictable, fast and scalable. Want more people on your site tomorrow? Raise the budget. No waiting for an algorithm to pick up organic posts, or six months for SEO.
The downside: they’re expensive, because you pay for creatives and placements, and you’re at the mercy of Meta and Google, which can reject ads, throttle your reach or ban your account.
What email is good and bad at
Email is commonly cited as returning around 4,000% on investment, roughly $40 for every $1, compared with something like 200% for paid ads. The reason is simple: once someone is on your list, you can show up in their inbox again and again for almost nothing. No platform fees, no new creative budget each time, and nobody can take your list away.
But you can’t do email alone. You can’t email strangers. People have to visit your site, see your pop-up and choose to join. Without traffic, your list stays empty.
Why they work best together
People generally need to see a brand several times before they trust it enough to buy (the “rule of seven”). If you rely on ads alone, you pay to reach the same person over and over, and you might barely break even on the first sale.
Put them together and it clicks:
- Someone clicks your ad and lands on your site.
- Your pop-up captures their email.
- Your email flows follow up automatically, which is retargeting for almost nothing.
One ad, many touchpoints, much cheaper.
The order matters: email first, then scale ads
The biggest mistake I see is brands pouring money into ads before their email backend exists. Traffic arrives, most of it bounces, and it never comes back. Do it in this order:
- Set up your email: pop-up, welcome flow, abandoned cart and the other core flows.
- Confirm they convert, so you know the backend works.
- Then scale ads, so every visitor you pay for actually gets put to work.
Email marketing isn’t dead. Lazy marketing is.
If all you do is email your products and hope people buy, they won’t. In their eyes, you’re just another brand pushing products. Here’s what the best brands do instead, with real examples:
1. Great copy and design
A grooming brand’s Christmas email used minimal copy and infographics. You understood it instantly: “Christmas bundles are here. Shop Christmas bundles.” Then it showed gift bundles for different types of people, scents, stocking fillers and an “Explore all” link, and ended with trust builders: all-natural, no fragrance oils, and a large customer count.
2. Address one objection head on
A drinks brand sent an email titled, essentially, “We’re not cheap.” It owned its price and explained why: better ingredients, intentionally made, real people behind it, quality. It worked because it tackled one concern, not ten, and was skimmable and on brand, with a footer at the end. Footers matter. From personal experience, some sales come from people browsing the footer.
3. Emotional and educational emails
Bite, an oral and body care brand, sent “Plastic is scary,” explaining why their products are plastic-free, how they differ from competitors and why they’re better for the planet. It makes buyers feel good about their choice. Another Bite email educated readers on two toothpaste ingredients, nHAp and fluoride, using infographics. People love learning about what they use. Show certifications in your footer if you have them.
4. Product-specific reviews
A wine brand’s email showed each wine with a review about that specific wine. Many brands make the mistake of using any random review. Match testimonials to the products you’re showing.
5. Product education
Magic Mind, a drinkable shot brand, broke down each ingredient by name and what it does. It’s educational and builds trust, with a CTA at the end.
6. Plain-text emails from the founder
Far too many brands don’t use these. A watch strap brand’s founder emailed customers who hadn’t bought during Black Friday, with an exclusive 30% code valid until the next day and a thank-you for being part of a small family business. Short, personal, and it converts like crazy. Mix these in now and then alongside your designed emails, and trust your data.
The common thread
- On-brand design with short, punchy, skimmable copy
- CTAs right in front of people
- One concern per email. Spread topics across multiple emails rather than cramming them into one.
Frequently asked questions
Is email marketing better than paid ads?
Neither is better on its own. Ads bring new people in quickly. Email turns those visitors into customers and repeat buyers cheaply. You need both to scale.
Should I set up email before running ads?
Yes. Get your pop-up and core flows live and converting first, then scale ads, so paid traffic gets followed up automatically instead of disappearing.
Is email marketing dead?
No. Lazy email marketing is, meaning emails that only push products. Brands that educate, handle objections, use specific social proof and send personal plain-text emails still get strong results.