Email strategy

Email Segmentation: Why Fewer Segments Make More Money

Prefer video? Watch the full tutorial on YouTube.

Quick answer

Too many segments can quietly kill email revenue, because you send far fewer emails overall. Use “mass first, target second”: send 3–4 campaigns a week to your whole engaged list (opened or clicked in the last 60 days), then layer at most one extra targeted send a week (two during BFCM or a big launch) to four segments: high-potential purchasers, VIP customers, category interest, and win-back.

The segmentation mistake smart marketers make

A brand owner discovers segmentation and learns the golden rule: right message, right person, right time. Then they build a segment for one-time buyers, two-time buyers, shoe browsers, accessory browsers, T-shirt buyers, California, Texas, 30 days inactive, 60 days inactive… Soon they have 15 segments, each getting its own campaigns. Six months later, email revenue is flat or falling, and they don’t know why.

The maths

Say you have 100,000 engaged subscribers.

  • Simple approach: four campaigns a week to your whole 60-day engaged list. That’s 4 × 100,000 = 400,000 emails a week.
  • “Clever” approach: split the list into small segments and send each one a tailored campaign. Your dashboard may look prettier and conversion rates may even rise, but each subscriber now gets far fewer emails. You might end up sending something like 80,000 emails a week, a fifth of the volume.

Personalised emails rarely perform five times better. More like 20–30% better, if you’re lucky. So you did more work, fragmented your data and made less money. Small segments starve you of volume, both the revenue it brings and the data you need to improve.

The framework: mass first, target second

Phase 1: your mass engaged baseline

Your main sending list is everyone who opened or clicked an email in the last 60 days. Send them 3–4 campaigns every week. No exceptions, no overthinking. That’s where 80% or more of your campaign revenue should come from. Nail just this, and you’ll outperform most brands.

Phase 2: targeted sends on top

On top of, not instead of. Once your baseline is consistent, add one targeted send a week (two during BFCM or a major launch) to these four segments only:

  1. High-potential purchasers: viewed a product, added to cart or started checkout in the last 30 days, but didn’t buy. Send one or two extra emails a month with an offer or a reminder of what they looked at.
  2. VIP customers: repeat buyers (for example 3–5+ orders). Give them early access and exclusive offers about once a month, or every couple of weeks in peak season.
  3. Category interest: people who browsed a specific collection, like winter jackets. Use it when you drop or discount that category, not every week.
  4. Win-back: customers who bought 90–150 days ago and have gone quiet. A monthly re-engagement email with a special offer and a reminder of why they loved you.

If you spend more time strategising targeted sends than creating your core campaigns, your priorities are backwards. Your engaged list is the money maker. Targeted sends are the cherry on top.

How to build these segments in Klaviyo

  • 60-day engaged: can receive email marketing AND (opened email at least once in the last 60 days OR clicked email at least once in the last 60 days). If open rates stay healthy (above about 25%), expand to 90 days. If you see deliverability problems, tighten to 30 days.
  • High-potential purchasers: can receive email marketing AND placed order zero times in the last 30 days AND (viewed product OR added to cart OR started checkout in the last 30 days).
  • VIP customers: can receive email marketing AND placed order at least 3, 4 or 5 times over all time. Pick your threshold.

5-question segmentation audit

  1. How many active segments do you have? More than 10 probably means you’re overcomplicating it.
  2. Do you regularly send to segments under 10,000 people? Unless your list is small, that’s a red flag.
  3. How much time goes on segmentation vs creating campaigns? More than about 20% on segmentation means simplify.
  4. What share of campaign revenue comes from your full engaged list? It should be around 80/20. If targeted sends make most of your money, your core campaigns need work.
  5. Could you keep this up if email revenue tripled tomorrow? If not, the system is too complex.

Action plan

  • Audit your segments this week and cut anything outside the four categories above.
  • Commit to 3–4 campaigns a week to your main engaged list.
  • Add one targeted send a week if you have the bandwidth.

The brands that make the most from email keep it simple: great campaigns sent consistently to their engaged list, plus a few targeted sends where they make sense. For deliverability-safe sending, see the deliverability plan.

Frequently asked questions

How many email segments should I have?

Usually one main engaged segment plus up to four targeted ones: high-potential purchasers, VIPs, category interest and win-back. More than 10 active segments is usually overcomplicating it.

Can too much segmentation hurt email revenue?

Yes. Splitting your list into many small segments usually means far fewer total sends, and the extra personalisation rarely makes up for the lost volume.

What is an engaged segment?

Subscribers who opened or clicked an email within a set window, commonly 60 days. Send most of your campaigns to them.