Klaviyo setup
18 Klaviyo Mistakes Costing You Revenue (and How to Fix Them)
In this guide
Quick answer
The Klaviyo mistakes I find most often in audits: Smart Sending left on in flows, no separate added to cart flow, sending from Klaviyo’s shared domain instead of your own, blasting the whole list (or the opposite, ignoring everyone outside your 90-day engaged segment), no sunset or preference page, a one-email post-purchase flow, and pop-ups that send people to their inbox for the code. Each is a quick fix, and together they add up to real revenue.
I audit a lot of Klaviyo accounts, for brands doing $50K a year and brands doing $5M a year, and I see the same mistakes again and again. Most brand owners don’t know they’re happening, because the numbers look fine on the surface. None of these fixes are secrets or cutting-edge tactics. They’re fundamentals that get skipped. Open your Klaviyo account and go through this list.
Flow mistakes
1. Smart Sending is on in your flows
Smart Sending stops someone from getting multiple emails from you within a set time window. It sounds helpful, but say someone abandons their cart and your flow should email them in an hour. If they got a campaign 30 minutes earlier and Smart Sending is on, they won’t get the abandoned cart email, your most important one. I’ve seen brands recover up to 50% more sends by turning it off.
Fix: open each email in your abandonment and post-purchase flows, click the clock icon (or the email’s settings) and untick Skip recently emailed profiles. Flow emails are triggered by behaviour, timely and relevant. Don’t let a random campaign block them.
2. You don’t really have an added to cart flow
Many brands see a flow called “Abandoned Cart” and think they’re covered. Check its trigger at the top. If it says Started Checkout, you don’t have a true added to cart flow. Someone who adds to cart is still browsing, so the messaging should be lighter (“Still thinking about it?”). Someone who started checkout got to the payment page, so be more urgent (“Complete your purchase”).
Fix: create a separate flow with the Added to Cart trigger. If you don’t have that metric, install it via Shopify first. Because far more people add to cart than start checkout, this flow can bring in more revenue than your checkout flow. If you’re just starting out, one combined flow is okay, but split them as you grow. Full guide: Klaviyo abandoned cart flow.
3. Your checkout flow is missing, broken or too short
Brands often have a checkout flow with the wrong trigger, or only two emails when it should be four or more. A proper started checkout flow:
- About 1 hour after: “Your order is waiting. Complete checkout.”
- About 12 hours later: “Still interested?” Show what they left, plus reviews.
- About 24 hours later: “We saved your cart,” with 10% off if you use incentives. No incentive in email 1, since many people convert from emails 1 and 2, which protects your margin.
- Later: “Last chance, your items might sell out.”
- Optional: a final plain-text email.
This should be one of your top three revenue flows. If it isn’t, something is broken.
4. No active on site flow
Very few brands have this. It emails people who visited your site but didn’t view a product or add to cart. The goal is the click, not the sale: bestsellers, customer stories, education or your USPs to get them back browsing. Create a flow with the Active on Site trigger and a short time delay. Full guide: Klaviyo site abandonment flow.
5. Your post-purchase flow is one email long
Straight after buying, a lot of customers wonder: did I just get scammed? Is this real? Will it actually arrive? That’s buyer’s remorse, and a lone shipping confirmation doesn’t fix it. Your post-purchase flow should remove doubt and build confidence:
- Answer the questions your support team gets most, before customers ask.
- Share usage tips or care instructions for what they bought.
- Set clear delivery expectations, so they’re not checking tracking every hour.
- Check in after delivery.
Give a great experience before you ask for anything. Then your review, UGC and second-purchase asks land much better. This is where lifetime value is built.
Add a real thank-you email from a person, like the founder or someone in customer support, right after purchase. No tracking info and no hard sell, just gratitude and an offer of help, with a soft upsell in the P.S. line, which almost everyone reads. Open and click rates are very high right after purchase. It works especially well in gifting season.
List and sending mistakes
6. Sending every campaign to your whole list
Not everyone on your list is engaged. Sending to people who haven’t opened in months hurts deliverability, costs more (Klaviyo charges per contact) and makes your metrics look terrible. One client had a 15,000-person list with only about 8,000 engaged. When we started sending campaigns to engaged segments, their open rate went from 19% to 45%, click rate rose to 2.8%, and they saved around $200 a month in Klaviyo fees.
7. …or only ever sending to your 90-day engaged segment
The opposite mistake. The number one predictor of campaign revenue is how many people you send to. If you have 150,000 contacts and only ever email 60,000, you’re paying for 90,000 people who never hear from you. Tier your sending instead:
- Engaged in the last 90 days: 1–3 campaigns a week.
- Engaged 90–180 days ago: one campaign every 1–2 weeks to re-engage them.
- Beyond 180 days: about one campaign a month.
How to build engaged segments in Klaviyo: create a segment with “Can receive email marketing”, plus Clicked Email at least once in the last 60 days OR Opened Email at least once in the last 60 days. Repeat for 30 and 90 days. Including both opens and clicks is a safety measure.
8. Never letting dead subscribers go
Create a sunset flow for people who haven’t opened or clicked in 120+ days: “We miss you, here’s what’s new”, then “Last chance” with an incentive like 15% off, then “Can we stay in touch? Click here or we’ll remove you.” If they still don’t engage, suppress them. A list of 5,000 engaged subscribers is worth more than 15,000 dead ones.
9. Unsubscribe is all or nothing
Many people don’t want to leave. They just want fewer emails. In Klaviyo, go to Settings → Other and edit your preference page and unsubscribe page so people can pause emails for 30 days, get fewer emails, or get sales-only emails. Then build a segment of people who updated their preferences and exclude them from heavy sends.
Deliverability mistakes
10. Sending from Klaviyo’s shared domain
By default, emails can go out from a shared Klaviyo sending domain that hundreds of other brands use, some of them spammy. Inbox providers notice. Set up a dedicated sending domain so emails come from your own domain, like hello@yourbrand.com. In Klaviyo, go to Settings → Email → Domains and follow the steps. You’ll add a few DNS records, and it takes about 15–20 minutes. I’ve seen open rates go from 60% to 75% from this fix alone.
11. All images, no text
Image-only emails can hurt deliverability. You don’t need to ruin your design. Add real text in your footer, like policies, a disclaimer and links, styled so it doesn’t distract.
Pop-up mistakes
12. Making people go to their inbox for the code
Someone is on your site, ready to buy, and your pop-up says “Check your email for your code.” Now they leave your site, find the email, copy the code and come back, hoping they remember what they were doing. Friction kills conversion. It also flatters your email metrics, because welcome flow revenue looks inflated while total revenue suffers. Show the code in the pop-up itself. The exception: if your deliverability is poor, sending people to their inbox can help your welcome flow’s engagement. Check your deliverability, then decide.
13. Asking for the email straight away
Use a two-step pop-up. Step one is a simple yes or no question, like “Want 10% off your order?” Step two collects the email (and phone number for SMS). The first click creates momentum. We’ve seen sign-up rates jump 20–30% just by splitting the ask. A/B test it. More on this in my Klaviyo pop-up guide.
Content mistakes
14. Your welcome email tries to do everything
Brand story, mission, values, catalogue, quiz, socials, all in email one. Most people signed up for the discount. Give them the code and a CTA, maybe a couple of reviews and links to your categories. When you cut the email down, conversions go up.
15. Breaking the only two design rules that matter
Most of your list opens email on their phone, so design for mobile first, and put a headline and CTA above the fold in every email. Those two matter more than fonts, palettes and template hierarchy. See Email design that converts.
16. No secondary CTAs in your footer
If someone reads to the bottom, they’re still interested. Give them somewhere to go: shop bestsellers, new arrivals, gift guides or accessories.
17. Never sending plain-text emails
Some of the best-performing emails look like they were typed in Gmail, from the founder, the team or customer support. They break the pattern of polished branded emails and feel human.
18. Running email and SMS separately
Coordinate them. For a flash sale: email 1 announces the sale and invites people to join SMS, SMS 1 says the sale is open, email 2 says it ends in 6 hours, SMS 2 is the final call. Use email to grow your SMS list and SMS for immediate action. Every few campaigns, invite email-only subscribers to join SMS. Follow the SMS laws where your customers are.
Frequently asked questions
Should Smart Sending be on in Klaviyo flows?
Turn it off for abandonment and post-purchase flows. Otherwise a recent campaign can stop someone from getting a high-intent email, like an abandoned cart reminder.
Do I need a dedicated sending domain in Klaviyo?
Yes. Sending from your own domain instead of a shared one improves deliverability. Set it up in Klaviyo under Settings → Email → Domains. It takes about 15–20 minutes.
Should I send campaigns to my whole list?
No, but don’t only email your 90-day engaged segment either. Send most campaigns to engaged subscribers, re-engage the 90–180-day group every 1–2 weeks, and email older contacts about once a month.
Should the discount code show in the pop-up or the email?
In the pop-up, so people can shop straight away, unless your deliverability is poor and you need the extra welcome flow engagement.