List growth
How to Create a High-Converting Pop-Up in Klaviyo
In this guide
Quick answer
To build a high-converting pop-up in Klaviyo: offer clear value that fits your brand, ask for one thing at a time (email first, SMS in a later step), show it after a short delay or scroll rather than instantly, make separate desktop and mobile versions, and keep the discount code simple. To go further, lead with a one-click question or a gamified format instead of a plain “Get 10% off” box.
Why most pop-ups underperform
Most brand owners set up a pop-up once, forget about it, then wonder why nobody subscribes. The generic version: someone lands on your site, and within seconds a box asks for their email in exchange for a small discount. No context, no connection. That’s not marketing, it’s a vending machine, and visitors treat it like one. They close it without thinking.
How to build a pop-up in Klaviyo
- Create the form. Go to Sign-up forms → Create form and pick a template. Klaviyo’s interface changes often, but the steps stay similar.
- Name it clearly and pick the list. Good names save you a lot of trouble once you’re testing several pop-ups.
- Choose the style. A standard pop-up is the safe default. Klaviyo also offers full-page, fly-out, embedded and banner styles. Set the size and image position.
- Write the offer. Make the value obvious, like a percentage off, money off, or exclusive access, depending on your brand and average order value.
- Keep step one minimal. Ask only for the email. If you do SMS, ask for the phone number in the next step. Never ask for email, first name, last name and phone up front.
- Show the code and a button on the success step, like “Start shopping.” In the button’s action settings, choose where it goes, for example a page on your site.
- Use a teaser on desktop. It works well there, but on mobile it can cover important things like add to cart and navigation.
Match the offer to your brand
A store with impulse products can lead with aggressive offers like 20–30% off. For high-ticket products, like jewellery costing thousands, 10% off isn’t very attractive, so offer something else that fits, such as exclusive access or early drops.
Keep the discount code simple
Use something like WELCOME15. If the code is a random string of letters and numbers, people can’t remember it, can’t apply it at checkout, get frustrated and leave.
Targeting and behaviour settings
- Don’t show it immediately. Give people time to see what you sell. Use a time delay of at least 5 seconds, a scroll trigger (I often use 50%) or exit intent.
- Frequency: if someone closes it, decide how many days before they see it again. I usually use 2 days.
- Devices: make separate forms for desktop and mobile. What looks good on one may not look good on the other, and most traffic comes from mobile. Quick way: build the desktop version, then Clone it, rename it “Mobile”, set targeting to mobile only and adjust the layout.
- Publish both versions.
Smarter pop-ups: use a question first
People want to finish what they’ve started. Psychologists call it the Zeigarnik effect, and it’s why you stay up finishing a show you weren’t even into. Smart brands use it: instead of opening with “Give me your email”, they open with a question. One click, low stakes. Once you’ve started, your brain wants to finish.
Strategy 1: a mini quiz pop-up
Imagine landing on a health brand’s site and the pop-up asks: “What’s your biggest health goal right now?” with four options. It’s a triple win:
- Higher opt-in rates, because the first click is easy.
- Smarter segmentation, because you know what each subscriber cares about from day one.
- Better emails, because the welcome email speaks to their exact goal instead of being generic.
Example: a skincare brand still offers a simple 10% off, but to claim it, you pick your main skin concern: dry skin, eczema, acne or a skincare swap. Their emails then recommend products, ingredients and customer stories for your concern. Same offer, much better packaging.
A simpler version: a two-step pop-up that first asks a yes or no question, like “Want 10% off your order?”, then collects the email. We’ve seen sign-up rates jump 20–30% just from splitting the ask into two steps. A/B test it.
Strategy 2: gamified pop-ups
Scratch-to-win pop-ups are taking off. Visitors scratch a panel to reveal their discount. The suspense makes it interactive, and once you “win” something, you’re primed to claim it, which makes a big difference compared to passively reading “10% off.” I use a pop-up tool called Alia for this. I’m not affiliated, I just think it’s the best for pop-ups.
Good friction vs bad friction
Friction isn’t the enemy. The wrong kind is. A boring form with lots of fields is bad friction. A one-click quiz or a scratch card is good friction. It creates investment, personalises the experience and makes signing up feel rewarding.
Common pop-up mistakes
- Asking for too much information up front
- No mobile version
- Showing the pop-up the instant someone lands
- No clear value. Tell people exactly what they get.
- Ugly, off-brand design. Spend real time making it look on brand.
- Sending people to their inbox for the code when they could see it in the pop-up (see Klaviyo mistakes)
Your action plan
- Add one question before the email field, about a goal, concern or preference, and watch your opt-in rate.
- Tag subscribers by their answer and personalise your welcome flow.
- Make sure your welcome flow is ready to turn those subscribers into customers.
Frequently asked questions
When should a pop-up appear?
Not instantly. Give visitors at least 5 seconds, or trigger it on scroll (around 50%) or exit intent, so they see what you sell first.
Should I ask for email and phone number in the same step?
No. Ask for the email first, then the phone number in a second step. Asking for everything at once makes people close the form.
Do I need separate pop-ups for mobile and desktop?
Yes. Layouts that work on desktop often don’t work on mobile. In Klaviyo, clone your desktop form and set its targeting to mobile only.
What is a quiz pop-up?
A pop-up that asks a one-click question, like your main skin concern or health goal, before asking for an email. It raises opt-ins and lets you personalise emails from day one.